Top 10 Pumpkin Butter Recipe Ideas


Advertisement

Time For New Cookware? This Is The Set For You

Tired of nursing flimsy pans that warp, scorch, and shed coatings faster than you can flip an omelet? Step up to the Legend 3-Ply Stainless Steel Cookware Set and cook with confidence for life. Triple-layer cladding delivers lightning-even heat, the riveted handles laugh at heavy stews, and each pot moves from any cooktop straight into a hot oven without breaking a sweat. Cleanup is quick, soap, water, done - so you’ll spend your evenings savoring that perfect steak instead of scrubbing it off the pan. No mystery coatings, no fussy seasoning rituals, just rock-solid stainless steel ready for generations of weeknight stir-fries and holiday roasts.

Read More on Amazon
Need a jar of silky Pumpkin Butter to spread on everything? These recipes show every tasty way to whip up this fall favorite, from quick stovetop batches to slow cooker and canning methods. Pick your flavor twist below and fill your kitchen with sweet harvest aromas.

What’s Great About Pumpkin Butter

  • Loaded with vitamin A and cozy spices
  • High-fiber spread that feels like dessert
  • Freezes beautifully for up to three months
  • Perfect on toast, pancakes, and waffles
  • Swirl into yogurt, oatmeal, or chia pudding
  • Doubles as a pumpkin pie filling shortcut
  • Makes an easy hostess gift in mason jars
  • Quick stovetop or hands-off crockpot prep
  • Dairy-free when made with coconut oil
  • Customizable with maple, honey, or brown sugar

Best Pumpkin Butter On Youtube

Explore these Easy Pumpkin Butter Recipe videos showcasing canning-friendly batches, slow cooker secrets, butternut pumpkin variations, and clever pumpkin pie inspired spreads. From a Crockpot Pumpkin Butter Recipe for effortless cooking to Canned Pumpkin Butter shortcuts, you will find fresh pumpkin options and smart Pumpkin Butter Uses for gifting, breakfasts, and desserts.

Easy Pumpkin Butter Recipe


This stovetop batch turns canned pumpkin and warm spices into a velvety spread in under 20 minutes. The texture is glossy and spoonable, tasting like pumpkin pie filling only richer.

Who Is This Recipe For:
Busy cooks who want quick results
Make it while your morning coffee brews and enjoy fresh toast toppers all week

Uniqueness:
Uses apple juice instead of water for natural sweetness
A splash of vanilla rounds out the flavor without extra sugar
Watch on YouTube

Pumpkin Butter Canning Recipe


Follow along as pressure-canning pro tips make a shelf-stable pumpkin butter that keeps flavors bright and safe for pantry storage. The spread stays thick and spreadable thanks to careful moisture control.

Who Is This Recipe For:
Homesteaders and meal-preppers
Prep big batches after pumpkin season sales to enjoy year-round

Uniqueness:
Includes headspace and pressure charts for multiple altitudes
Adds lemon zest for zing and extra acidity
Watch on YouTube

Butternut Pumpkin Recipes – Butter in a Jar


Sweet butternut pumpkin is roasted first, deepening caramel notes before it’s puréed into butter. The end result is silkier than canned purée and naturally sweeter.

Who Is This Recipe For:
Fresh-produce lovers and gardeners
Ideal for using up surplus butternut from your harvest

Uniqueness:
Roast-first technique concentrates flavor
Cinnamon sticks simmer in the pot for gentle spice infusion
Watch on YouTube

Pumpkin Pie Recipe – Butter Version


This old-fashioned pumpkin butter is cooked down until it tastes just like the custard from a classic pie, minus the crust. Spoon it straight onto graham crackers for instant pie vibes.

Who Is This Recipe For:
Dessert fans chasing that pumpkin pie flavor hit
Great for no-bake cheesecakes and holiday parfaits

Uniqueness:
Uses brown butter to deepen autumn notes
Finishes with a pinch of sea salt for balance
Watch on YouTube

Homemade Pumpkin Butter


Slow simmering on the stovetop thickens this butter until it spreads like soft caramel. Balanced spices keep the pumpkin flavor front and center instead of masking it.

Who Is This Recipe For:
Traditionalists who love classic methods
Perfect weekend project that perfumes the whole house

Uniqueness:
Includes a clever spoon test for doneness
Suggests stirring leftovers into morning lattes
Watch on YouTube

Homemade Pumpkin Butter Recipe


From carving-pumpkin scraps to gourmet spread, this tutorial shows how to roast, purée, and season for unbeatable freshness. The texture is ultra creamy with toasted sugar undertones.

Who Is This Recipe For:
Zero-waste cooks and flavor seekers
Perfect after Halloween when pumpkins are plentiful

Uniqueness:
Calls for a dash of smoked paprika to enhance depth
Demonstrates water-content tweak for thicker consistency
Watch on YouTube

Pumpkin Butter Recipe Crockpot


Toss everything in the slow cooker, set it, and wake up to a kitchen filled with autumn aroma. The long low heat caramelizes sugars for a deep, jammy flavor.

Who Is This Recipe For:
Busy families and set-and-forget fans
Ideal for overnight cooking so breakfast is ready at dawn

Uniqueness:
Combines crockpot convenience with optional canning steps
Uses maple syrup instead of granulated sugar for richness
Watch on YouTube

Canned Pumpkin Butter Recipe


Learn the step-by-step water-bath technique to seal pumpkin butter safely. The spread stays bright orange and spoon-thick after months on the shelf.

Who Is This Recipe For:
Gift givers and pantry stockers
Make holiday baskets that wow friends with homemade flair

Uniqueness:
Includes spice-infused sugar syrup for even flavor
Demonstrates jar inversion trick for tighter seals
Watch on YouTube

Fresh Pumpkin Recipes – Beginner Butter


Starting from raw pumpkin chunks, this beginner-friendly guide shows roasting, puréeing, and spicing for a farm-fresh flavor that canned just cannot match.

Who Is This Recipe For:
Farmers market enthusiasts
Great for showcasing heirloom pumpkin varieties

Uniqueness:
Uses a sheet-pan steam method for speedy roasting
Suggests stirring finished butter into savory soups
Watch on YouTube

Pumpkin Butter Uses – Endless Ideas


After demonstrating the simplest stovetop butter, this video dives into creative serving ideas like layering in parfaits, glazing chicken, and folding into cream cheese.

Who Is This Recipe For:
Culinary tinkerers and snack lovers
Perfect when you need inspiration for leftover butter

Uniqueness:
Features a tasting board of ten flavor pairings
Shows how a dash of espresso powder heightens pumpkin notes
Watch on YouTube
Affiliate Disclosure: "As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases made from the following suggestion. I am a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon.com."