Creamy Butterfinger Pie Variations You’ll Want To Try
This page organizes creative takes on butterfinger pie so you can pick a style, grab a tip, and make dessert happen fast. Skim the combos, choose a tool, then open the ideas directory to watch, learn, and bake the version that fits your cravings today.
What’s Great About Butterfinger Pie
No Bake Ease The Butterfinger Pie No Bake Cheesecake Swirl idea sets quickly and keeps the kitchen cool for stress free dessert nights.
Freezer Friendly Butterfinger Pie Frozen Greek Yogurt gives you a lighter, frosty texture that keeps beautifully for make ahead plans.
Short Ingredient Lists Butterfinger Pie 3 Ingredient Fudge Mousse proves you can get big flavor with a tiny shopping list.
Party Ready Slices Butterfinger Pie 4 Ingredient Icebox Bars cut clean and travel well for potlucks and game days.
Loaded Crunch Butterfinger Pie Snickers Caramel Crunch doubles down on candy bits for texture in every bite.
Kid Approved Portions Butterfinger Pie Peanut Butter Pudding Cups make tidy single serves that chill fast.
Sheet-Friendly Butterfinger Pie Caramel Delight Slab bakes or chills flat so you can feed a crowd without fuss.
DIY Mix-Ins Butterfinger Pie Homemade Candy Crumble lets you control chunk size for a custom bite.
Jar Convenience Butterfinger Pie Easy Cheesecake Jars layer neatly for clean storage and quick gifting.
Custard Comfort Butterfinger Pie Baked Custard Slice offers a silky, old school finish with a candy twist.
Recommended Tools For Butterfinger Pie
Cuisinart 9-Inch Springform Pan
Ideal for chilled pies like no bake cheesecake swirl so slices release cleanly.
Buy on AmazonPyrex 9-Inch Glass Pie Plate
Great for classic setups, baked custard slices, and easy fridge to table serving.
Buy on AmazonHamilton Beach 6-Speed Hand Mixer
Whips cream cheese fillings smooth for mousse cups and frozen Greek yogurt variations.
Buy on AmazonKitchenAid 3.5 Cup Mini Food Chopper
Quickly pulses cookies and candy for homemade crumble and crusts.
Buy on AmazonExtra Combo Suggestions For The Recipes Below…
Oreo Truffle Crust + Cheesecake Swirl Blend cookies with a little cream cheese to anchor the Butterfinger Pie No Bake Cheesecake Swirl with deeper chocolate notes.
Greek Yogurt Ripple + Honey Fold a honey ribbon through Butterfinger Pie Frozen Greek Yogurt for balanced tang and sweetness.
Salted Caramel Drip + Slab Warm a quick caramel and drizzle over Butterfinger Pie Caramel Delight Slab for shiny bakery vibes.
Peanut Butter Ganache + Mousse A simple peanut butter ganache caps the Butterfinger Pie 3 Ingredient Fudge Mousse with fudge shop richness.
Pretzel Crunch + Icebox Bars Swap in pretzel crumbs for the Butterfinger Pie 4 Ingredient Icebox Bars to add salty snap.
Snickers Bits + Extra Crunch Stir mini Snickers into Butterfinger Pie Snickers Caramel Crunch for double candy texture.
Whipped Pudding Top + Cups Top Butterfinger Pie Peanut Butter Pudding Cups with whipped topping and shaved candy for a party finish.
Toasted Peanuts + Candy Crumble Fold warm toasted peanuts into Butterfinger Pie Homemade Candy Crumble for roasty depth.
Jar Layers + Chocolate Sauce Stripe Butterfinger Pie Easy Cheesecake Jars with chocolate sauce for sundae energy.
Custard Slice + Cinnamon Sugar Dust Butterfinger Pie Baked Custard Slice lightly with cinnamon sugar for cozy café flair.
Best Butterfinger Pie On Youtube
Craving creamy peanut butter filling, candy bar crunch, and a crust that behaves every single time. This collection lines up recipe ideas that show how to nail no bake cheesecake swirl, quick 3 ingredient fudge mousse, and freezer friendly frozen Greek yogurt riffs. You will also see icebox bars for clean cuts, pudding cups for portion control, and a caramel delight slab that feeds a crowd. Use the notes to match your skill level, pantry, and timeline, then pick the take that fits tonight.
Butterfinger Pie Frozen Greek Yogurt
Cool and tangy Greek yogurt lightens the usual peanut butter cream, while crushed candy adds the snap you want. Freeze until sliceable for a frosty texture that still eats rich. It is a simple churn free approach that keeps prep short.
Who Is This Recipe For:
Dessert lovers who want a lighter bite without losing the candy crunch
Great for warm evenings or after a hearty dinner when you want something cold
Uniqueness:
Uses strained yogurt to stabilize the filling without gelatin
Freezer set method gives clean slices with a creamy center
Butterfinger Pie No Bake Cheesecake Swirl
A cheesecake style base whips cream cheese with peanut butter for a thick, tangy body. Swirl in a touch of vanilla cream and fold through candy crumbles for texture. Chill in a cookie crust and slice.
Who Is This Recipe For:
Fans of classic cheesecake who want no bake speed
Perfect when the oven is busy or the day is hot
Uniqueness:
Swirl technique creates a marbled look without extra tools
Oreo or graham crust options let you tune sweetness
Butterfinger Pie 3 Ingredient Fudge Mousse
Whip together a fast trio for a fudgy, airy mousse that carries Butterfinger crumble like a champ. The texture is spoonable yet sturdy enough for a pie shell. Minimal shopping, maximum payoff.
Who Is This Recipe For:
Minimalists and busy weeknights
Great when you need dessert in under an hour of chill time
Uniqueness:
Three pantry staples keep it foolproof
Fudge like flavor with mousse lightness
Butterfinger Pie 4 Ingredient Icebox Bars
Layer a simple filling over a crumb base, chill hard, then cut into tidy bars. The candy bits stay crisp while the center sets velvety. It travels well and plates clean.
Who Is This Recipe For:
Potluck planners and bake sale stars
Best for make ahead trays you can slice and serve
Uniqueness:
Four ingredient method keeps steps short
Bar format means no messy wedges
Butterfinger Pie Snickers Caramel Crunch
Blend chopped Butterfinger with Snickers bits and a light caramel drizzle for sweet salty crunch. The filling stays fluffy while pockets of nougat and peanut pop in every bite. A crowd pleaser that feels playful.
Who Is This Recipe For:
Candy fans who want extra texture
Ideal for birthdays or movie nights
Uniqueness:
Two candy mix in approach adds layers of crunch
Quick caramel drip finishes it like a bakery pie
Butterfinger Pie Peanut Butter Pudding Cups
Whisk a peanut butter pudding base and spoon into cups with cookie crumbs and candy layers. The texture is silky and kid friendly, and the chill time is short. Top with whipped cream for a simple finish.
Who Is This Recipe For:
Families and portion control eaters
Perfect for lunchbox treats or quick desserts
Uniqueness:
Individual cups set faster than a full pie
Layered build gives a parfait style look
Butterfinger Pie Caramel Delight Slab
Spread a thick filling across a sheet style base, then stripe with caramel for shiny slices. The slab format chills evenly and cuts into generous rectangles. It is a low effort way to feed many.
Who Is This Recipe For:
Hosts feeding a crowd
Great for church suppers, team parties, and holidays
Uniqueness:
Sheet pan shape means even layers and fast chilling
Caramel finish adds gloss and a buttery note
Butterfinger Pie Homemade Candy Crumble
Pulse candy to your favorite crumb size and fold into a rich peanut butter cream. Bigger bits give bolder crunch while fine crumbs blend into the base. Adjust to taste for a custom bite.
Who Is This Recipe For:
Texture lovers who want control
Best when you have mixed candy sizes to use up
Uniqueness:
DIY crumble lets you tune the crunch factor
Works with Oreo, graham, or shortbread crusts
Butterfinger Pie Easy Cheesecake Jars
Build no bake cheesecake cream in small jars with candy ripples and crumb layers. The texture is thick and spoonable, and the lids make them travel safe. Keep a few chilled for instant dessert.
Who Is This Recipe For:
Meal preppers and gift givers
Handy for picnics, road trips, and bake sales
Uniqueness:
Jar format controls portions and keeps layers neat
Easy to customize with sauces or extra crumble
Butterfinger Pie Baked Custard Slice
Bake a simple custard base in a crust, then finish with candy on top for a firm slice. The set is smooth and sliceable, and the warm notes play well with peanut butter. Chill fully before cutting for sharp edges.
Who Is This Recipe For:
Fans of classic baked pies who want a candy twist
Serve at holiday dinners or whenever you want a sturdier slice
Uniqueness:
Baked custard foundation holds shape on a dessert table
Candy finish adds crunch and color without glazing