Apple Butter Recipe Ideas: Browse Our Top 10 Picks


Advertisement

Time For New Cookware? This Is The Set For You

Tired of nursing flimsy pans that warp, scorch, and shed coatings faster than you can flip an omelet? Step up to the Legend 3-Ply Stainless Steel Cookware Set and cook with confidence for life. Triple-layer cladding delivers lightning-even heat, the riveted handles laugh at heavy stews, and each pot moves from any cooktop straight into a hot oven without breaking a sweat. Cleanup is quick, soap, water, done - so you’ll spend your evenings savoring that perfect steak instead of scrubbing it off the pan. No mystery coatings, no fussy seasoning rituals, just rock-solid stainless steel ready for generations of weeknight stir-fries and holiday roasts.

Read More on Amazon

Apple butter takes the humble apple and cooks it into a silky-smooth spread that’s equal parts nostalgia and versatility. A directory of apple butter recipes helps you jump from slow-simmered classics to speedy desserts without hunting all over the internet.

What’s Great About Apple Butter

  • Concentrated apple flavor with minimal added sugar
  • Rich source of pectin and natural fiber
  • Fat-free spread that replaces oil in baking
  • Pairs with sweet or savory dishes—from toast to pork chops
  • Works as a glaze for meat and roasted veggies
  • Long shelf life when canned or frozen properly
  • Instant flavor boost for oatmeal, yogurt, or smoothies
  • Deep caramel notes enhance cookies, muffins, and pies
  • Ideal filling for cakes, donuts, and hand pies
  • Easy to make in crockpot, stovetop, or pressure cooker

Best Apple Butter On YouTube

From a Homemade Apple Butter Recipe that simmers down to velvet, to Easy Apple Butter Muffins and a Crockpot version that practically cooks itself, these ten videos cover Apple Butter Desserts, canning know-how, Apple Butter Pie, Stove Top shortcuts, and clever Recipes Using Apple Butter. Dive into the lineup and find your favorite fall flavor fix.

Homemade Apple Butter Recipe


Description: Tart apples simmer with cinnamon until they melt into a deep-brown, spoon-thick spread that tastes like autumn in a jar. Slow cooking caramelizes the sugars, giving a rich, buttery finish without actual butter.

Who Is This Recipe For:
Home cooks who love classic, no-gadget methods
Perfect for weekend batch cooking and holiday gifting

Uniqueness:
Peel-optional technique preserves nutrients
Requires only apples, spices, and patience for big flavor

Watch on YouTube

Apple Butter Cake (Apple Butter Desserts)


Description: Think spice cake turned up to eleven—apple butter adds moisture, cinnamon warmth, and a caramel hue that bakes up irresistibly tender.

Who Is This Recipe For:
Dessert lovers craving a fuss-free fall bake
Great for potlucks when you want big flavor without frosting drama

Uniqueness:
Replaces most of the oil with apple butter
Results in a lighter crumb yet richer taste

Watch on YouTube

Apple Butter Canning Recipe


Description: A small-batch method that walks you through safe water-bath canning so your apple butter stays shelf-stable and flavor-packed all winter.

Who Is This Recipe For:
Homesteaders and meal-preppers
Ideal for stocking the pantry or prepping gifts months ahead

Uniqueness:
Uses lemon juice balance for acidity
Step-by-step canning tips remove the guesswork

Watch on YouTube

Apple Butter Pie


Description: Creamy custard meets spiced apple butter in a pie that bakes up silky and slices clean—no apples to soften, just pure flavor.

Who Is This Recipe For:
Pie fans looking for a twist on pumpkin pie
Perfect make-ahead dessert for Thanksgiving

Uniqueness:
Six-ingredient filling whips up in minutes
Apple butter provides both sweetness and structure

Watch on YouTube

Apple Butter Recipe Crockpot


Description: Dump-and-go slow cooker method lets apples cook overnight until spreadable, filling your home with warm cinnamon aroma.

Who Is This Recipe For:
Busy cooks who prefer set-it-and-forget-it meals
Handy when stove space is at a premium during holiday prep

Uniqueness:
No-stir recipe avoids scorching
Optional canning segment included for long storage

Watch on YouTube

Easy Apple Butter Recipe


Description: Quick prep, everyday spices, and clear visuals make this a foolproof starter apple butter that still develops deep caramel flavor.

Who Is This Recipe For:
Beginners intimidated by long cook times
Great weeknight project while you binge a show

Uniqueness:
Granny Smith base balances sweet and tart
Detailed spice ratios prevent over-seasoning

Watch on YouTube

Apple Butter Cookies


Description: Soft, chewy cookies that fold apple butter straight into the dough for a snickerdoodle-meets-spice-cake flavor punch.

Who Is This Recipe For:
Cookie jar guardians seeking new flavors
Perfect with coffee or tucked into lunchboxes

Uniqueness:
Eliminates need for extra liquid sweeteners
Rolls in cinnamon-sugar for crackly tops

Watch on YouTube

Apple Butter Recipe Stove Top


Description: A brisk stovetop simmer concentrates apples in just over an hour, boosted by one surprise ingredient for extra depth.

Who Is This Recipe For:
Apartment dwellers without slow cookers
Ideal for small batches when you crave instant gratification

Uniqueness:
Uses maple syrup for subtle smokiness
No peel waste—everything cooks down until velvety

Watch on YouTube

Apple Butter Muffins


Description: Fluffy muffins baked with a full cup of apple butter for moisture, plus warm spices that make the kitchen smell like a cider mill.

Who Is This Recipe For:
Breakfast bakers needing grab-and-go treats
Perfect weekend project with kids—no mixer required

Uniqueness:
Evaporated milk and lemon juice boost tenderness
Sprinkle of sugar on top creates a crackly crust

Watch on YouTube

Creative Recipes Using Apple Butter


Description: A roundup of clever ways to slip apple butter into glazes, sauces, and baked goods—think pork tenderloin, overnight oats, and puff-pastry roses.

Who Is This Recipe For:
Cooks who already have jars to use up
Handy when you’re hunting for weeknight flavor hacks

Uniqueness:
Covers both sweet and savory ideas
Emphasizes apple butter as a fat-swap in baking for lighter treats

Watch on YouTube
Affiliate Disclosure: "As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases made from the following suggestion. I am a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon.com."